Failure to State a Claim

A foster child filed a personal injury lawsuit (rather, a lawsuit was filed on his behalf) against those responsible for his care after they allegedly failed to provide him with proper dental care. He claims he had a serious pain in his teeth that his caregivers ignored, and that he might suffer lifelong injuries as a result.

The lawsuit names several defendants: the Children’s Network of Southwest Florida LC, Camelot Community Care, Lutheran Services Florida, and two Lutheran Services employees. All of the defendants filed a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim. The court granted the Children’s Network’s and Camelot’s motions, but gave the child 30 days to file an amended complaint.

What Is Failure to State a Claim?

Failure to state a claim (officially called failure to state a cause of action) is an affirmative defense under Florida law that allows defendants to question the legal basis for the lawsuit. This defense is most likely to succeed when the plaintiff doesn’t follow the state’s pleading requirements.

Specifically, the plaintiff’s complaint “must state a cause of action” and contain:

• “a short and plain statement” arguing why the court has jurisdiction (the legal authority to decide the case)
• “a short and plain statement of the ultimate facts showing that the pleader is entitled to relief,” and
• a demand for judgment (the relief that the plaintiff is requesting).

If the complaint is deficient, the court might give the plaintiff an opportunity to correct those mistakes.

Filing an Amended Complaint

After filing their original complaint with the court, Florida plaintiffs are allowed to amend it one time before serving it on the defendant. Subsequent amendments require court approval. To get this approval, the plaintiff must file a motion to amend the complaint and attach the proposed amendment. The court then has discretion to grant or deny the plaintiff’s request.

(While you might be able to amend your original complaint, it’s better to compile a valid complaint in the first place, which is why you should consult an attorney before filing your lawsuit.)

There is also something called a supplemental pleading, which allows plaintiffs to include transactions or events that happened after filing the original complaint. The plaintiff must first file a motion with the court, which will decide whether to permit the supplemental pleading. Like the original complaint, the plaintiff must serve the supplemental pleading on the defendant and provide notice of the new claims.

Legal procedures like these can be confusing. An experienced attorney can explain pleading requirements (like stating a claim and filing amended complaints) and everything you need to know about the litigation process. 

Contact Us Today

Contact a Fort Myers personal injury attorney at The Pendas Law Firm today for a free consultation if you were the victim of negligence. We will guide you through the litigation process and help recover the compensation that you deserve.

The Pendas Law Firm also represents clients in the Jacksonville, West Palm Beach, Miami, Orlando, Tampa, Fort Lauderdale, Daytona Beach and Bradenton areas.

Resources:

flarecord.com/stories/511456825-judge-allows-foster-child-to-amend-complaint-in-negligence-case-grants-motions-to-dismiss-by-two-defendants

floridabar.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Civil-Procedure-Rules-Updated-3-8-18.pdf