Skip to main content

Exit WCAG Theme

Switch to Non-ADA Website

Accessibility Options

Select Text Sizes

Select Text Color

Website Accessibility Information Close Options
Close Menu

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Consumer Expectation Test Over Risk Utility Test in Product Liability Cases

In late October, the Florida State Supreme Court reached a decision upholding the use of the “consumer expectations test” in some product liability cases. The consumer expectations test is used to determine whether or not the user of a product should expect it to be dangerous if used in the correct way. This ruling overturns a previous district court ruling that said the “risk utility” test should be used in product liability cases.

About the Case

In Aubin v. Union Carbide Co., a Florida man claimed he contracted mesothelioma by working with products containing asbestos mined by Union Carbide. The man originally won a $6.6 million in damages but the ruling was overturned by the district court. The court said that in this case the risk utility test should be used to determine the outcome of the case. The risk utility test determines whether the benefit from using a product in a responsible manner outweighs the risk of harm from the way it is made. This test clearly benefits manufacturers of faulty products as they can win in product liability suits if their dangerous products do enough net good for the user.

The Florida State Supreme Court stepped in and overturned the district court’s ruling and reinstated the consumer expectations test. The Supreme Court justified this decision, claiming that the consumer expectations test better adheres to the doctrine of strict liability, the legal doctrine for liability without proving fault.

The decision is a victory for consumers who now have an easier time proving the dangers of a defective product without having to consider the positive utility of the product.

Product Liability Cases

Product liability cases arise when a person is injured or killed by a defective product. The injured party has grounds to sue the manufacturer, wholesaler or distributor, depending on the situation and specific defect. These cases can pertain to manufacturing defects, where a product is unintentionally made defective in the manufacturing process, and design defects, where the original blueprint of the product was flawed leading to the creation of a dangerous product.

There are three types of product liability lawsuits: negligence, strict liability and breach of warranty. In negligence suits, the plaintiff must prove that carelessness in the design and manufacturing of a product led to his or her injuries and that the defendant had a duty to sell a safe product. In strict liability cases, the plaintiff only has to prove that the product was defective and an injury occurred, and the case does not consider whether or not the manufacturer used extreme care when making the product. Breach of warranty cases relate to when a manufacturer breaches any guaranteed expectation of the safety of a product, whether explicitly stated or implied.

Contact a Florida Product Liability Lawyer Today

The world is filled with dangerous and poorly designed products that can leave you or a loved one seriously injured. At the Pendas Law Firm, our skilled Florida lawyers can help you stand up to the large corporations that carelessly design dangerous products. Contact us today for a free consultation.

Read What Others Have To Say About Us

  • I can't express how much I appreciate this law firm. I had the honor to deal with attorney Daniel. He kept me updated on my case. I couldn't ask for a better law firm...

    — Terry Mcphillips
  • Speedy & superb handling of clients & cases, kind & caring. Highly recommended professionals. They made everything very easy for us, were outgoing & polite. I would call them again if ever in need, rather than call the larger firms that need to advertise & brag about winnings...

    — Joseph Kestell
  • Wow I called Pendas Law Firm the other day at their main intake line it was around 11 o’clock at night and I’ve got this wonderful representative his name was Jeffrey Alvarez. This guy was very professional and his compassion was out of this world..

    — Luis Sanchez
  • Thank you for helping us in our time of need. This firm handled my father’s workers comp case, and helped us with every question we had, and we had a plenty. Thankful for the entire legal team!

    — Enilno Resu
  • I just concluded a case with attorney Michael Sanchez and paralegal Camilo Lopez. I can only say they are exceptional. The customer service is unique, they have been battling alongside me since day 1. They are not only courteous and professional, but they also are amazing at their job...

    — Israel Garcia
  • Their attorneys are absolutely someone you want handling your car accident claim. They communicated with us promptly and thoroughly. I was very happy with our recovery. Already recommended them to others in the same circumstances, their staff speaks Spanish and you feel like in family.

    — Ian Brito
  • Very Professional law firm. They explained to you every detail what to do according to the laws (worker's compensation). Mr. Danilo Cruz is the best Lawyer and his team. They are very kind, friendly, responsible, I love this firm. They fight for their clients. AwesomeTeam!

    — Lau Rod
  • I am very proud and happy that my case was closed, and definitely won! Lizette Gonzalez was my case manager and I definitely recommend this P.A.! Honestly, no other lawyer even tried to fight my case at all, I was turned down by most of those who I called...

    — KingArroyoVEVO
  • Great lawyers who speak Spanish and English. Danny Cruz and Lizette Gonzalez helped with my case and put my parents worries at ease. They got my case over and done with within a year and helped get all my bills paid.

    — Caroline Matute
  • This was a positive, informative and pleasant experience concerning an unpleasant situation. Everyone I spoke to was very professional and compassionate. I always felt to be in the best and most capable hands. the Pendas Law Firm lives up to its reputation!

    — Jean Villarreal
  • Pendas Law did an awesome job working my claim against my homeowners insurance. They had refused to pay for the wind damage to the roof. Larry with Pendas Law Firm was assigned to my case and immediately started working on it. I could not be happier. Will definitely use Pendas Law in the future if needed.

    — John Hibbert
  • I'm thankful to have chosen them , very responsible and communicative , Went in the office with my family and the environment was great ,Sahily walked me through the process professionally, I got a good settlement faster than I expected, would totally recommend.

    — Juan Fernandez
  • I'm very happy with this firm... Joel is an excellent attorney and Carolyn is an amazing paralegal, After been ditched from another law firm, Pendas took care of me and they won my case. I recommend them 100%...

    — MARIA PASTOR
  • This law firm is amazing. I love how they always try to stay/keep in contact with you. It shows that they really care and want everything taken care of correctly, Thank You!...

    — SHANTELLE BLACKWELL
  • I'm very thankful for all the attention of all the Pendas staff that took care of my case and helped me through the process, thanks for your patience, collaboration and comprehension!...

    — CARLOS GUADALUPE
  • The Pendas Law Firm was amazing! They are very kind, professional, and hard-working! They always kept me informed. Larry Trias was great to work with! I always recommend Pendas to family and friends. Thank you for helping me with my case!

    — HEATHER PEPPER
  • Their attorneys are absolutely someone you want handling your car accident claim. They communicated with us promptly and thoroughly. I was very happy with our recovery. Their staff speaks Spanish and you feel like family.

    — IAN BRITO
  • I would definitely recommend this firm. The staff really helps you and they actually show you that they care, especially Siomara Roldan. She has been a great help for my family and myself, she is always helpful with any questions.

    — WILMER D SANTANA RODRIGUEZ
  • Pendas is the best! The paralegals are very attentive to your case, knowledgeable, and communicative! The attorney also won’t just be there the day of your sign up, but all throughout the process as needed. I truly recommend Pendas!

    — MCKENZIE CZABAJ
  • Previous
  • Next
 

By submitting this form I acknowledge that form submissions via this website do not create an attorney-client relationship, and any information I send is not protected by attorney-client privilege.

Florida Personal Injury Offices

Skip footer and go back to main navigation