Switch to ADA Accessible Theme Close Menu
Florida Personal Injury Lawyers
$3,830,000

Catastrophic motorcycle accident resulted in a jury verdict.

$1,748,000

Auto accident, multi-car crash

$1,035,000

Auto accident involving defective airbag

$600,000

Death resulting from hospital turning away patient

$550,000

Auto accident involving tractor trailer

$345,000

Auto accident involving a work vehicle

$340,000

Slip and fall at a hotel bathroom

$115,000

Auto accident involving pedestrian. $115,000 in litigation instead of $15k presuit offer

Call: 844-200-0000
Free Initial Consultation
Do you opt in to being contacted via SMS texting or phone call?
 
protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms

Supreme Court Limits Jurisdiction in Personal Injury Lawsuits

LegalAdvice

It’s not enough to have a viable personal injury complaint against a negligent defendant — you also have to file that complaint in the proper court. Otherwise your claims can be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

What Is Jurisdiction?

There are two types of jurisdiction: subject matter jurisdiction and personal jurisdiction. Subject matter jurisdiction refers to a court’s authority to hear a particular type of claim, or subject matter. For example, a federal bankruptcy court is specifically charged with deciding bankruptcy cases. Personal jurisdiction refers to a court’s power over particular parties in a case. In other words, courts don’t have blanket authority to decide cases involving every person in the world. The party must have certain minimum contacts with the jurisdiction in question.

The U.S. Supreme Court recently issued a decision in a case asking whether a Montana court had personal jurisdiction over an out-of-state corporation. The court held that Montana’s jurisdictional rule violated the U.S. Constitution and limited where companies can be sued in personal injury lawsuits. That decision, while targeted at Montana, affects every court in the country, including here in Florida.

The Lawsuit

The Supreme Court case involved two lawsuits filed by two different parties against the same company, BNSF Railway. The first lawsuit was filed by a North Dakota man who claimed he injured his knee while working for the railroad in Washington state. The second lawsuit was filed by a South Dakota woman whose husband worked for the railroad in three different states. She claimed that he developed cancer while working for the railroad and blamed the company for his death.

They both filed their lawsuits in Montana, which has a rule claiming personal jurisdiction over “persons found” in the state. While BNSF has railway lines in Montana, it is incorporated in Delaware and has its principal place of business in Texas. The fact that a company does business in a particular state does not satisfy the constitutional test (minimum contacts) for personal jurisdiction, the Supreme Court held.

What Does This Decision Mean for Me?

The most important takeaway for personal injury plaintiffs is that you have to be careful when selecting a jurisdiction in which to file your lawsuit. If your claims are dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction then it will cost more time and more money to refile your claims in the proper court. Moreover, depending on when you filed your claims initially you might run up on statute of limitations issues (the statutory deadline for filing your claims). That is why you should always consult with an experienced personal injury attorney. 

Let Us Help You with Your Case

If you or a loved one has been injured because of someone else’s negligence, you might be entitled to compensation. Contact a Fort Myers personal injury attorney at The Pendas Law Firm today for a free consultation. We will help you determine whether you have a viable claim, against what parties, and where to file the lawsuit.

The Pendas Law Firm also represents clients in the Miami, Fort Lauderdale, Orlando, Jacksonville, Tampa, West Palm Beach, Daytona and Bradenton areas.

Resources:

scotusblog.com/2017/05/opinion-analysis-court-restricts-lawsuits-state-railroads/

natlawreview.com/article/states-may-not-hale-out-state-railroad-no-personal-jurisdiction-supreme-court-rules

Read What Others Have To Say About Us

  • “I can’t express how much I appreciate this law firm. I had the honor to deal with attorney Daniel. He kept me updated on my case. I couldn’t ask for a better law firm. Daniel fought for me til the end and got me what I deserved. Thanks Daniel and your team for always being there to answer any of my questions. If I ever need a law firm again...”

    Terry Mcphillips
  • “Speedy & superb handling of clients & cases, kind & caring. Highly recommended professionals. They made everything very easy for us, were outgoing & polite. I would call them again if ever in need, rather than call the larger firms that need to advertise & brag about winnings…Pendas was a pleasant & more personal approach instead of...”

    Joseph Kestell
  • “Wow I called Pendas Law Firm the other day at their main intake line it was around 11 o’clock at night and I’ve got this wonderful representative his name was Jeffrey Alvarez. This guy was very professional and his compassion was out of this world I don’t know what I would do if I could not have got a hold of him...”

    Luis Sanchez
  • “Thank you for helping us in our time of need. This firm handled my father’s workers comp case, and helped us with every question we had, and we had a plenty. Thankful for the entire legal team!”

    Enilno Resu
  • “I just concluded a case with attorney Michael Sanchez and paralegal Camilo Lopez. I can only say they are exceptional. The customer service is unique, they have been battling alongside me since day 1. They are not only courteous and professional, but they also are amazing at their job. Thanks to them I got a great deal. I am glad I decided to use their services...”

    Israel Garcia
  • “Their attorneys are absolutely someone you want handling your car accident claim. They communicated with us promptly and thoroughly. I was very happy with our recovery. Already recommended them to others in the same circumstances, their staff speaks Spanish and you feel like in family.”

    Ian Brito
  • “Very Professional law firm. They explained to you every detail what to do according to the laws (worker’s compensation). Mr. Danilo Cruz is the best Lawyer and his team. They are very kind, friendly, responsible, I love this firm. They fight for their clients. AwesomeTeam!”

    Lau Rod